How to Build a Soultribe: Step Three, The Unpacking

basking in the glow of passover with my monkfish abbey soultribe
This is an ongoing series about How to Build Your Soultribe. Click here for step one and step two, or follow me on Twitter for notification when a new post is up. To listen to this post click here.
A couple weeks ago, Portland artist Jolie Guillebeau wrote to me via Twitter:
“I have a dilemma and I wonder if you can help. How do you properly grieve the loss of your Soultribe, without being bitter?”
Ah, the ten million dollar question!
Part of getting ready for your new Soultribe involves saying goodbye to your old one. I’ve been a part of several meaningful tribes in my past: small groups at church that became and extended family; a group of friends who wanted to build a co-housing together; a group of seekers trying to provide soulcare to one another over beer, bread, and a bowl of soup. Each one of them brought me the gifts I needed at the time I needed them. But leaving them was difficult. The first was closed out of exhaustion. The second ended after mysterious interpersonal fall-outs. The third ended when we decided to move overseas. Each goodbye came with a confusing mix of emotions: anger, gratitude, fear, expectation, sadness, relief.
I am not known for making a graceful exit. I stay too long until I am sick and bitter; or I rush to leave too abruptly. But I am learning a little about leaving a Soultribe–what you take with you, and which bits you have to unpack before you can feel at home again.
Unpacking the Anger
We often leave our Soultribe because of a falling out. This is sad, but what’s the point of pretending it’s not true? Religious groups fight over doctrine. Communes collapse under the strain of what to do with the common purse. Writer’s groups get fed up with each other’s feedback. It happens, and it’s maddening. Here are two things I find helpful in dealing with anger.
1) Honor your Anger. The best way to get bitter is to ignore your angry feelings. Many of you know that I used to have an anger altar in my backyard where I could throw plates at a heap of stones. That’s because I believe anger packs a lot of heat, and discharging that energy can be helpful. But if you can’t find a place to break things, you can honor your anger in other ways. Tell a friend your anger story. Write it down. Collage an image of it. Give it a great big seat of honor on your mantelpiece. I promise it will help.
2) Find the Primary Emotion. Once when I was very angry, a friend told me “anger is a secondary emotion.” At the time, I wanted to throw something hard at his head. But later I realized how helpful this advice was. Anger is indeed real – but it is also a cloaking device. The red hot heat of anger hides other more primary emotions behind its flashy showmanship. When I am angry, and I’ve already ranted and raged in some plate breaking sort of way, I then complete the dealing-with-anger practice. I sit down, usually with a pen and a notebook. I close my eyes. I thank my anger for being an early warning system. Then I ask it to step aside so I can see what is behind it. (Hurt feelings? Not feeling listened to? Disappointment?) Then I get to work on paying attention to that emotion. It works every time.
To Every Season, Change, Change, Change
When I was in my twenties I spent a few weeks at JPUSA—a commune in the poorest part of Chicago. JPUSA had been around since the era of the Jesus Freaks. I was in awe. These people had lived common purse, in families of choice, at poverty level for decades. That was the kind of community I longed for – one rooted in service and place—one with longevity.
What I did not understand was that Soultribes exist for a season. They serve a certain purpose for a certain time. And while some like JPUSA go on for a long time, the reality is their membership is in constant flux. People come and go. Relationships change. Goals alter. And you know what? That’s how it’s meant to be.
Sometimes it’s that the group dynamic which changes, and what you started with morphs into something strange and unfamiliar. Sometimes you change and what once fit and supported you no longer serves you well. When that happens there are three things I find helpful
1) Make a Good Ending. If a group blows up in a mess of bad feelings, this may not be possible. But if you are attentive to the seasonal shifts in yourself and in your group, you can take your leave in a way that creates shalom rather than illness. To make a good ending: give plenty of notice; carve out some time with the tribe to remember what you’ve done together; express thanksgiving to the people you shared so much life with. This can be both incredibly restorative, and emotionally draining—but it’s worth it.
2. Make space for sadness. Leaving your Soultribe often brings about a sense of sadness and loss. Grieving takes time, comes in cycles, and needs you to honor it. One of my favorite tricks for dealing with this process is a shrine for sadness. The simplest version is to clear a space on your window sill (I like to give the process sunlight and fresh air), find a pretty bowl, and gather some pebbles. Every time you remember something sad, or recall something you miss about your community, put a stone in the bowl. What this communicates to your soul is: this is real, this is what you are supposed to feel, there is a space for this sadness.
3) Memorialize The Real. Sometimes when a community closes you can get thrown into a cycle of self-doubt. Was it really as good as you remembered? Were you ever really friends? Had it actually ever fed you? Because we humans are complicated, any tribe we build is a mixed bag. But it’s rare that something you’ve lived in has been a complete bust. Don’t let your gremlins tell you otherwise! Find a way to memorialize the good about your lost tribe. Write a list of true things on a long coil of paper. Make a slide show of your photographs from that era. Read your journal from the time you spent with them. These things will help you remember The Real, and embody the message that while your tribe was not permanent, it was valuable and treasured.
What Soultribe have you left behind? What did you experience? How did you take your leave? What tricks do you have to help you mourn, remember, and celebrate?













February 20th, 2009 at 11:49 pm
I’m still mourning a writing group I left behind 10 years ago. Although my gut impulse is to sneak out of town, I did the leaving right (going away party and all) and have a frame full of photos to remind me of the time we spent together.
I’m putting a bowl with stones on my studio windowsill right now to remember and honor the sadness I still feel.
February 21st, 2009 at 1:01 am
These are wonderful posts. Thank you for these.
February 25th, 2009 at 5:35 pm
This is beautifully written and so true.
I could identify with all you’ve written. I’ve definitely felt all of the feelings you’ve mentioned.
My soul tribe right now, has been together for 7 years. Many have come and gone. Some of the leavings have been graceful, some not. We keep getting better at it. The last family that came and went gave no notice. I was left hurt and feeling anger and a lot of self-doubt (was it my fault, can I fix it). Even though the family left with kind words, I felt like I still needed to process this with my tribe. At the next gathering we talked together, about what we’d miss about this family. We also reflected on who we were as a group and gave each other permission to continue to be ourselves, even if others didn’t like it (Ugh. That sounds so egocentric, but I think it has to be that way.)
The last family that moved in and out of our group left b/c they moved back to their homeland in Australia. They led our last gathering and we all talked about joy and sorrow and how they go together. We lit candles, we cried and it felt so right. They assured us that the sorrow is okay. That letting them go will open up a space for something or someone else. It was meaningful on so many levels. I wish we could say goodbye to everyone like this.
March 12th, 2009 at 1:24 pm
[...] made some space, you’ve written your mantra to evoke a mood, and maybe you’ve even unpacked a few things so your new Soultribe can move in. Now comes the part that is both difficult and glorious: just add [...]